Unwanted Tier 1 subscription still billing after duplicate charge – refund and goodwill credit requested
Status: Closed · Asked by Anthony on · 0 views
Hi Anthony,
Thank you for reaching out and for sharing your concerns in detail. We sincerely understand the frustration that unexpected subscription charges can cause, especially when identified during your accounting review. We appreciate your patience while we reviewed the billing history.
After carefully checking the account, we would like to clarify a few important points:
Pabbly allows users to maintain multiple active subscriptions under the same account. At the time of your previous conversation, there was no request to cancel the Tier 1 subscription specifically, and therefore it remained active.
The Tier 1 subscription had a scheduled renewal date of September 28, 2026. The initial payment attempt was unsuccessful, and the system successfully processed the renewal on a subsequent retry on October 2, 2026.
It is the account owner's responsibility to manage active subscriptions. If assistance is ever needed regarding active plans or cancellations, our support team is always available to help.
The subscription you previously referred to in ticket TCK-220455 was the duplicate Unlimited subscription. That subscription was canceled and refunded at the same time once the issue was verified.
Regarding the refund request for the Tier 1 charges:
We could not find two separate Tier 1 charges totaling $38 as mentioned in your email.
Our records show only one successful $19 Tier 1 renewal charge. Therefore, the claim of being charged $38 for the Tier 1 plan is not supported by the billing records.
Additionally, the October 2, 2026 charge was not the first charge for this subscription. As per our billing policy, we are unable to issue a refund for this renewal payment.
With respect to your request for complimentary service for November and December 2026, or an equivalent account credit, we truly understand the reasoning behind your request. However, we would not be able to provide complimentary subscription periods, account credits, or compensatory allowances in this case.
We understand this may not be the outcome you were hoping for, and we genuinely regret any confusion caused by having multiple active subscriptions. If you no longer wish to keep the Tier 1 subscription active, we can certainly assist with ensuring it remains canceled going forward.
Thank you for your understanding and for being a valued Pabbly customer. Please let us know if you need any assistance reviewing your current active subscriptions, and we will be happy to help.
Hi Adeel,
Thank you for the reply. To correct my earlier message: the Sep 28 Tier 1 attempt failed and went through on Oct 2, so the Tier 1 charge was $19 once, not twice.
The point stands, though. No customer on an Unlimited plan has any reason to also pay for Tier 1. Unlimited already includes everything Tier 1 offers. When I wrote in about being charged for a second subscription, a support team looking out for its customers would have noticed a redundant plan on the same account and pointed it out. Instead we were offered task credits twice before getting the refund we asked for, and now a $19 charge on a plan we clearly never needed is being defended as policy.
Please cancel the Tier 1 subscription today and confirm here once it's done.
For some time we've had the option to move our automations to Zoho Flow, which is already included in our Zoho One subscription. We've stayed with Pabbly out of habit. Given how this has been handled, I'm asking our technical team to start that migration now, and we'll cancel our Unlimited plan once it's complete.
Thank you,
Anthony Soleimon
VA Plus LLC
Hi Anthony,
Thank you for your candid feedback and for taking the time to explain your perspective. We genuinely understand where you're coming from.
We acknowledge that after upgrading to the Unlimited plan, maintaining a Tier 1 subscription did not provide any additional benefit to your use case. While multiple active subscriptions can exist within a Pabbly account, we understand why the additional Tier 1 renewal charge felt unnecessary given your intention to use the Unlimited plan going forward.
As a goodwill gesture and in recognition of the situation, we can add $19 in account credits to your Pabbly account. These credits will be automatically adjusted against the next renewal of your Unlimited plan.
Additionally, we will cancel the Tier 1 subscription, ensuring that you will not be charged for that plan again in the future.
We sincerely regret the inconvenience and frustration this experience has caused. We truly value your business and appreciate the time you have spent with Pabbly. While we're sorry to hear that you're considering other alternatives, we hope this gesture demonstrates our commitment to resolving the matter fairly and maintaining your trust.
Please feel free to reach out if you need any further assistance. We're always happy to help.
Hello Anthony,
I hope you’re doing well. I just wanted to follow up regarding my last message.
Hello Anthony,
I trust you’re doing well. I wanted to check in regarding the message I sent earlier.
Hello Anthony,
I hope this message finds you well. I’m following up on my previous email. Further, this is our last follow-up email. The ticket will be closed automatically as we have not received a reply. Further, we have added $19 credits to your account which will be utilized in the upcoming renewal of your Pabbly Connect Unlimited Monthly plan. You can email us again at support@pabbly.com to raise your concern.
